Saxmundham B V Bury St Edmunds C

SCCA Division 3 Tue 5th Apr 2022 00:00 Winner: Draw   Verify
Board Rating Saxmundham B V Bury St Edmunds C Rating
1826 (1841) Gaffney, Samuel
G
1 - 0
N
Default
0000 ()
1711 (1802) Usher, Michael E
N
½ - ½
G
Bradshaw, Craig
1348 (1548)
1333 (1315) Brown, Hugo E
B
½ - ½
G
Webb, Mark
1400 (1414)
1400 (1311) Cartwright, Paul
N
0 - 1
B
Robinson, George
1396 (1456)
Total 6270 2 - 2 4144

Last update Sam Gaffney Tue 19th Apr 2022 07:15. Reported by Sam Gaffney Wed 6th Apr 2022 07:35. Verified By Mike Usher Wed 6th Apr 2022 07:38

Press / Admin Comment

Bury C had a player withdraw through illness and defaulted on board 1.

Craig Bradshaw

Ineligible Player

George Robinson is rated 1396 in the January rating list. This is higher than the nominated Board 4 player (Craig Bradshaw with a rating of 1348). Therefore the result of the game is reversed for the purposes of the league standings.

Sam Gaffney

Inelligible Player Appeal Ruling

Whilst it was clear to the SCCA President that fielding George Robinson breached the intent of the rules, the SCCA had failed to actually draft the rules to follow through on the intent. Therefore, he ruled the penalty be reversed.

Sam Gaffney